Dawkins’ delusion

Richard Dawkins, in “The God Delusion” (2006) describes God thus:

“The God of the Old Testament is arguably the most unpleasant character in all fiction: jealous and proud of it; a petty, unjust, unforgiving control-freak; a vindictive, bloodthirsty ethnic cleanser; a misogynistic, homophobic, racist, infanticidal, genocidal, filicidal, pestilential, megalomaniacal, sadomasochistic, capriciously malevolent bully.”

This trope has been taken up by the entertainment industry in various forms. You hear it a lot. Setting aside, for the moment, the absurdity of rejecting God based on His purported attributes (if there is a God then He can be whatever He darn well pleases, - one would think), let’s take each of these adjectives in turn and see if they hold up:

Unpleasant. Well, I suppose I could concede this one, a bit. God is a fearsome, awesome, terrifying being. To be unregenerate in his presence would truly be “unpleasant”. Thankfully, we have an advocate who shields us from Gods fierceness, so we should be good there. Still, He is not a tame lion…

Petty. A petty person is one who is stingy, reluctant, cold. Try this one on from Malachi 3:10 (there are many more like it): “Test me in this,” says the Lord Almighty, “and see if I will not throw open the floodgates of heaven and pour out so much blessing that there will not be room enough to store it.” Hmm, not so petty.

Unjust.  Here again I have to agree. God IS unjust. We do not all get what we deserve. We deserve Hell but can get heaven. Looked at another way, a lot of us do get what we deserve. God has clearly outlined his requirements, and we are free to follow or not. The result is in accord with the rules so specified. No injustice here. Some will argue that the injustice lies in predestination, which is a tricky subject (see post on freedom). But predestining those you foreknow will freely choose to follow or not still leaves the choice with the person and does not make God unjust.

Unforgiving. “Let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts; let him return to the Lord, and He will have mercy on him; and to our God, for He will abundantly pardon.” Isaiah 55:7. Enough said.

Control-freak. Hmm. I recall a comedy sketch by Rich Little about JFK and RFK, who had a liking for football: JFK: “If you want to play ball, you will play ball my way or not play ball at all. And you know why.” RFK: “No, I don’t know why.” JFK: “It’s my ball”. The universe is God’s. No surprise He gets to call the shots.

Vindictive. I’m assuming this is in reference to visiting punishment on those who disobey and therefore directly related to the above point on injustice. For God to say: “Follow these rules and all will not only be well but magnificent. OR, disobey and things will go badly” is hardly vindictive. We have got to stop blaming others (God) for the consequences of our own choices.

Bloodthirsty. Well, here is a point. From the very beginning the issue was “Obey or die”. Clear enough. If we chose death that is hardly God’s fault. But I think the point here is more directly related to the next one.

Ethnic cleanser.  So, this must be the usual bellyaching about the Amorites, and some others, that God instructed the exodus Jews to annihilate. Some assumptions, and very anachronistic to our contemporary culture, were that:

1) annihilation of people groups was some sort of weird aberration. It was not. Wiping out entire cities, villages, nations was SOP in that day and age. God is not mandating something humans are not already doing.

2) The Amorites were some kind of docile, peace-loving, organically-farming hippies that were unlucky to be standing the way of the mighty Jews. They were not. Recall Gen 15:16b: “for the iniquity of the Amorites is not yet complete”. The nature of the iniquity is not spelled out in detail though historically involved child sacrifice, sexual licentiousness and violence.

3) The exodus Jew were explicitly instructed not to harm other surrounding people groups, so we are not talking about some demented jihad throughout the Levant.

4) Further, we have ample evidence for large scale retribution for injustices committed even in our own day and age: viz. the Nüremberg Trials. Compared to the Amorites the Nazis were pussycats.

Misogynistic.  Hmm, God created Eve. Deborah is a Judge and hero, as is Esther. Abigail is wise and politically astute in protecting her lout of a husband from David… Don’t see misogyny here, particularly when the cultures surrounding the Jews often treated their women worse than slaves.

Homophobic. God is not afraid of homosexuals. The problem is that homosexuals, by and large, choose to behave in opposition to God’s laws with the resultant effects. (See point on injustice above).

Racist. This is a confusing one. Jews are not a “race” but an ethnicity. But to argue that in choosing the Jews as His people God is somehow rejecting everybody else is to, again, be ignorant of what Scripture actually says:  Gen 22; 18 “and through your offspring all the nations on earth shall be blessed”.

Infanticidal. More confusion here. There are three big episodes of infanticide in Scripture: 1) The killing of boys under two years of age by Pharaoh to prevent the emergence of Moses, 2) The Passover death of Egyptian first born (not strictly speaking infants) , 3) The slaughter of the innocents (males under two years of age) in Bethlehem by Herod the Great to prevent the emergence of Jesus the Messiah. 1 and 3 were not perpetrated by God but by men and 2 was a direct consequence of not obeying Gods command through Moses to let his people go (and likely retribution for #1).

Genocidal. Once someone starts repeating themselves you know they are out of steam. Please see “Ethnic cleanser” above.

Filicidal. Since Dawkins is restricting his argument to the “old testament” God, one can only assume that he is referring to Gods commandment to Abraham to sacrifice Isaac. But we know how that turned out. I suppose there are episodes where righteous Jews turned on their apostate brethren (eg: Exodus 32 27ff where apostate Jews were killed by their brothers). Please see section on Vindictive above.

Pestilential. Hmm, pestilence. This must be in reference to the plagues of Egypt. Again, a direct consequence of human decisions.

Megalomaniacal. More repetition. Please see “Control freak” above. But then, you could hardly blame him. He IS God after all. I guess we are to take “maniacal” in the sense of disturbed and/or deranged. But if you really are Omniscient, Omnipresent, Omnipotent, then there is no derangement. So, you are not a maniac.

Sadomasochistic. This is a curious way to describe someone who, out of Love, lays down His life for those who hate him. I suppose the issue is really harking back to the problem of evil. But, see “Malevolent” below.

Capricious. James 1:178: “Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom there is no variation or shadow due to change.” There are instances in Scripture where God “relents” or “changes His mind”, but since He clearly remains within His own will, there is no capriciousness. Only Grace. Now, take Zeus, or any of the other “gods” of the ancient Middle East and you will see what capriciousness is really like.

Malevolent. See above. Malevolence suggests designing cruelty for its own sake and Scripture (should you bother to read it) shows no sign of God being like that. Ezekiel 33:11: Say to them, “As I live”, declares the Lord GOD, “I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way and live; turn back, turn back from your evil ways, for why will you die, O house of Israel?”

Bully. A bully is someone who forces you to do what he wants, most often in a violent manner. A God who lets you freely choose whether to follow Him or not and lets you live your life more or less in peace (for as long as THAT lasts) is hardly a bully.

Finally, if this is all fiction, who cares? Nobody raises invectives like this against Hamlet, or Macbeth, or Achilles. Why all the fuss over a fictional character? “There is no God, and we hate him”. Well, knock yourself out.

Previous
Previous

Patriarchy

Next
Next

Jesus and freedom